Close Alert Banner
Close Old Browser Notification
Browser Compatibility Notification
It appears you are trying to access this site using an outdated browser. As a result, parts of the site may not function properly for you. We recommend updating your browser to its most recent version at your earliest convenience.
Skip to Content

Middlesex Mutual Insurance Logo

Middlesex Mutual Insurance Logo

Middlesex Mutual Insurance

Contact Us Main menu icon
Get a QuoteFind an Agent or BrokerReport a claimContact UsLoginPayment Options
  • Home & Property
    Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Loss Prevention Services
    • Recreational Insurance
    • Rental Property Insurance
    • Umbrella Liability Insurance
    • Water Shield (Overland Flood)
  • Auto
    Insurance
    • Commercial Auto Insurance
    • Commercial Fleet Insurance
    • Types of Vehicles Insured
  • Farm
    Insurance
    • Loss Prevention Services
    • Supplementary Coverage Options
    • Umbrella Liability Insurance
  • Commercial
    Insurance
    • Commercial Auto Insurance
    • Commercial Fleet Insurance
    • Commercial Insurance Packages
    • Crime Insurance
    • Directors and Officers Insurance (Not-For-Profit)
    • Loss Prevention Services
    • Umbrella Liability Insurance
  • Claims Support
    • Report a claim
    • Loss Prevention Services
    • Claims Guide
  • Who We Are
    • Board of Directors
    • Community Spirit Pledge
    • Contact Us
    • Covid-19 Information Hub
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Financial Statements
    • Find an Agent
    • News and Stories
    • Ontario Mutuals
    • Payment Options
    • Policies
    • Get a Quote
    • Staff/Departments
Middlesex Mutual Insurance Logo
banner1

Doing the Right Thing!

Means we care

Find out what we can do for you.

Get a Quote

Find an Agent or Broker

Report a Claim

Discover Middlesex Mutual. Insuring with us is like coming home.

Who we are. A Mutual Insurance Company established over 140 years ago to support our community with high quality, reliable insurance at a reasonable cost. Owned and directed by our policyholders. We do not have shareholders, so we really can put our customers first!

Our promise. Exceptional personal service for you, based on our principles of fairness, integrity and understanding. You will find we are clear, open and transparent, so you know where you stand.

Locally owned and operated. Located in the center of Middlesex County, we offer insurance coverage to communities where we also work and live. Communities such as Ailsa Craig, Denfield, Ilderton, Lucan, Parkhill, Thorndale and surrounding areas. This enables our group of talented staff and agents to offer insurance that is well suited to your needs.


AMALGAMATION NOTICE

 

October 31, 2022

 

The Boards of Directors of McKillop Mutual Insurance Company and Middlesex Mutual Insurance Co. are excited to announce that we have entered into an agreement in principle to amalgamate effective January 1, 2024.

Following a thorough comparative analysis of our respective organizations, we have concluded that by combining forces, the new organization will be in an even better position to confidently and effectively overcome whatever challenges the future may hold and to meet the expectations of our members for many years to come. We are extremely proud of the many years of service we have provided to our respective members and communities.

The companies will be working together over the next several months developing a transition plan and securing the necessary member and regulatory approvals.

Any questions can be directed to the CEOs of either company.

Mutually yours,  
 
Gary Goertz
Chair, Board of Directors
Middlesex Mutual Insurance
 
Christina Gummerson
Interim President and CEO
Middlesex Mutual Insurance
1-800-851-4045
cgummerson@middlesexmutual.on.ca
 
Dorothy Medd
Chair, Board of Directors
McKillop Mutual Insurance
 
Rob Moorehead
President and CEO
McKillop Mutual Insurance
1-800-463-9204
rob@mckillopmutual.com

 

Family carrying boxes from a moving van

Home Insurance

It's your home whether big or small and as the saying goes, there's no place quite like it. That’s why choosing the proper insurance is such an important decision. It’s more than just price. It’s about choosing a company that is going to be there when you need us most.

Helping you protect your home and belongings is our business. Let us show you how.

man and woman driving in a car with sunlight shining through window

Auto Insurance

When you insure with Middlesex Mutual, you're placing your trust in a neighbour. Someone who lives in your community and drives the same roads that you do. We're familiar with the driving conditions you face each and every day. We're proud to offer local personal service that's a little different.

Talk to a Middlesex Mutual agent about your car insurance. We will help keep you moving.

man showing a woman something on an ipad

Business Insurance

In our communities, a business is more than a sign or a storefront. It’s a familiar face behind the counter. When you insure with Middlesex Mutual, you are placing your trust in a neighbour. We have both business and family roots in the community just like you.

Middlesex Mutual offers a full range of business packages specifically tailored for your type of business. We are here to help, please give us a call.

alt

Farm Insurance

The farm is the heartbeat of a rural community. For many people, whether it's been in the family for generations or part of a larger operation, it's both home and business. At Middlesex Mutual, we understand that choosing the right insurance program is an important part of the success of any farming operation.

Let us show you how.

Middlesex Mutual News

Loading News Feed...

alt

News and Stories

 

Keep up to date with all of the latest news from Middlesex Mutual Insurance.

Follow Us

View our Facebook page View our Twitter page View our Instagram page

Middlesex Mutual's logo

Middlesex Mutual Insurance

15 Meredith Dr.
PO Box 100
Ilderton, ON N0M 2A0
Get Directions

Toll Free: 1-800-851-4045

Phone: 519-666-0075

Fax: 519-666-0079

Email us

Office Hours

Weekdays: 8:30 a.m. - 4:30 p.m.

Saturday and Sunday: Closed

A Proud Member Of

Ontario Mutuals logo

Middlesex Mutual's company logo

  • Login

  • Contact Us
  • Employment Opportunities
  • Accessibility
  • Website Feedback
  • Privacy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap
  • Design by eSolutionsGroup
x